Brazilian president approves regulatory framework for sports betting, igaming

Bill 3,626/2023 was signed into law by the head of state on 30 December.

President Lula’s approval came after Brazil’s chamber of deputies voted on 21 December to endorse the bill. Igaming was added back into the bill after previously being removed by the senate.

According to reports in Brazil, President Lula vetoed a proposed income tax exemption for customer earnings of under R$2,112 (£339/€394/US$425). Personal net winnings will be taxed at 15%.

Brazil regulation: Taxes

Operators will be taxed at 12% of gross gaming revenue, with the bulk of the total allocated to sports development. Taxation recommendations were submitted by the Economic Affairs Commission on 22 November.

Fixed-odds bets will be allowed under the new law, with the country’s ministry of finance responsible for regulating operators.

Five-year licences will be awarded, with companies paying R$30m for up to three brands – two fewer than previously expected.

Brazil regulation requirements

Operators must offer customers self-exclusion windows that range from 24 hours to six weeks. They must also have a Brazilian board member who will hold at least 20% of the company’s share capital.

Companies must also verify the identities of bettors – all of whom must be over 18 years old – through facial recognition technology.

Brazil’s regulation – what are the next steps?

The next steps will include the ministry of finance publishing regulatory guidelines for operators.

In total, more than 130 businesses are reportedly interested in applying for licences.

Neil Montgomery, founder and managing partner of Brazilian law firm Montgomery & Associados, explains what we’re going to see.

“Given the need for the Ministry of Finance to issue a number of administrative norms (called Portarias, in Portuguese) further regulating the different topics covered by the Bill of Law, with the same also being put to public consultation before they become effective. It is more likely that Brazil will see a regulated market operating in the second half of 2024.” He says.

This should give sufficient time for operators that have not yet established themselves in Brazil to set up their own structures (and select their Brazilian partners if required) to do so.

“They will also be required to file their applications for a federal licence (with those having submitted their expressions of interest to the Ministry of Finance under Portaria No. 1,330/23 purportedly to benefit from a faster review of their applications).

“The will also need to satisfy all other legal and regulatory requirements (such as paying the expensive BRL30 million license fee and hiring the necessary members of staff for the key positions laid down by the new legislation).” He finished.

Inclusion of igaming after initial removal “only natural”

The incorporation of igaming into Bill 3,626/2023 came after it was previously removed by the senate.

Commenting, Hugo Baungartner, vice-president for global markets at Brazilian casino operator Aposta Ganha, said: “This was an absolute victory for the whole industry. That was something that we were fighting for, at least 15 years.

“That was the first step for Brazil. The other verticals and markets will come with time and conscience. We now expect the first technical meeting on 10 January.”

Senator Carlos Portinho’s amendment excluding igaming initially passed with 37 votes in favour and 27 against. Despite this, the chamber of deputies retained the authority to overturn that decision. It utilised its power to do exactly that.

Neil Montgomery feels the financial benefits of igaming meant its inclusion in the bill was inevitable, stating: “It was only natural that igaming be re-included into the bill.

“To the extent that most of the revenues for operators come from igaming rather than from fixed-odds sports betting and the federal government wanted to collect as much tax as possible.”

Hugo Baungartner agrees that the financial allure of including igaming has outweighed the largely evangelical opposition.

“The government knew that igaming was crucial for their 2024 budget,” Baungartner said. “I could say that was a master play from them.

“They [the opponents to igaming’s inclusion] always existed and will exist. However, they have to understand that the gambling business is a reality in Brazil.

“They were, are and will be against gambling forever. Every time that an attempt was made, they did big noise, including an association to work in the contrary.”

Predictions for the first year

When asked for his predictions for the first year of the market, Montgomery also had plenty to speak about on the subject. The market’s regulation has certainly been a long time coming.

“As a Brazilian gaming lawyer for nearly two decades, this is the moment I have been waiting for all this time (and was betting my chips on). I expect there to be an avalanche of foreign direct investment (and also M&A and joint venture activity) and so a bounty of legal work to do.

Indeed, the presence of operators now on Brazilian home soil (which is a first for local betting customers), will certainly mean plenty of activity from a legal standpoint.

“With the establishment (finally) of foreign operators in Brazil, there could also be an initial wave of litigation by disgruntled customers. They will now have a door to knock on in Brazil, it was previously very difficult to sue them here.

If all this does indeed happen, you will certainly see a larger Montgomery by the end of the first year!

Entain adds Eminence Capital CEO Sandler to board

The new appointment is effective immediately, with Sandler joining the Entain board. 

He will also become a member of Entain’s People & Governance and Capital Allocation committees. With the former, Sandler will support Entain in identifying an additional non-executive director mutually agreeable to Eminence and Entain.

Sandler founded New York-based Eminence Capital in 1999, leading the organisation as its CEO for over 25 years. He also serves as chief investment officer.

Prior to this, he co-founded Fusion Capital Management and spent time as a research analyst for Mark Asset Management Corporation. 

Entain chair talks up “substantial” growth opportunities

Reflecting on his appointment, Sandler said he was pleased to be joining a business with “enviable” positions in markets worldwide. He added that he is looking forward to supporting Entain with its long-term growth plans.

“Entain is a robust business with market-leading brands, a unique technology platform and enviable positions in key geographies around the world,” Sandler said. “I look forward to working with my fellow directors to help Entain achieve long-term success and create lasting value for its shareholders.”

Entain chairman Barry Gibson also welcomed the appointment. He said Sandler would help the group pursue what he described as “substantial” growth opportunities.

“I am pleased to welcome Ricky to the board of Entain,” Gibson said. “Ricky has a deep knowledge of our business and a firm belief in the quality of our operations and substantial growth opportunities.  

“We look forward to benefiting from his perspectives and expertise as we work to drive value for all Entain shareholders.”

Sandler urged Entain to offload BetMGM stake, critical of STS deal

Sandler’s appointment comes as no surprise, having been mooted last month by the Sunday Times.

What makes the appointment perhaps more interesting is his previous comments about Entain selling off its stake in BetMGM. Sandler has previously called on Entain to sell all or part of the BetMGM joint venture with MGM Resorts.

Sandler also penned an open letter to Entain in June 2023 criticising its acquisition of STS in Poland. Entain brokered the deal earlier in the same month and went on to complete the £750m (€865m/$948m) purchase in August.

At the time, Sandler outlined how Eminence had a 2.1% stake in Entain and held shares since 2020. He also spoke about how Eminence held regular talks with management at Entain about its plans to maximise shareholder value.

However, Sandler hit out at Entain’s decision to fund the STS acquisition by issuing shares representing approximately 8% of its market cap. Sandler branded the move as “perplexing on many levels”. 

“While we can support the company pursuing seemingly rational acquisitions, funding them with highly undervalued equity is an empire building, shareholder value destroying strategy,” Sandler said at the time. 

“Further, that the Entain board has previously rejected multiple takeover approaches at materially higher prices on the grounds that those offers undervalued the company, but then turn around and issue equity at depressed prices for an asset that is at best a ‘nice to have’ is illogical.”

Sandler raised concerns over share price

Sandler also highlighted how Entain’s share price fell 8% in the days after the deal was announced. He said this led to more than £650m being lost in market value.

This led to him openly criticising Entain’s board and management team, describing them as “tone deaf”.

“We can assure you that this particular shareholder is outraged and in light of the movement in the company’s share price we are clearly not alone in that sentiment,” Sandler said. “As shareholders lose confidence in Entain’s ability to allocate capital and create long term value, it is quite likely they will support a sale of the company to MGM at a materially lower price than previously assumed.

“Eminence will continue to make its voice heard in an effort to ensure Entain’s board and management do not make any further value destructive decisions.”

Change at the top for Entain

Sandler’s appointment also follows last month’s departure of Jette Nygaard-Andersen as CEO of Entain.

Nygaard-Andersen resigned in mid-December, with non-executive director Stella David becoming interim chief executive. This led to a series of changes in the boardroom and within board committees. 

Entain appointed board member Pierre Bouchut as senior independent director, replacing David. Virginia McDowell was named chair of the Remuneration Committee, with Gibson becoming chair of the People and Governance Committee. 

Finally, Rahul Welde was appointed as a member of the People and Governance Committee.

Nygaard-Andersen’s resignation came days after Entain resolved a case with the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) in reference to historic activities in Turkey.

The terms saw Entain agree to pay a £585.5m (€679.0m/$740.8m) financial penalty, as well as a £20m charitable donation and £10m to HMRC and CPS costs.

STS names new chair and CEO

In related news, STS last month also announced changes to its own management team

Radim Haluza became the operator’s new chief executive, while also remaining as CEO of Entain CEE. Long-serving STS chief executive Mateusz Juroszek switched from that role to become chairman of the supervisory board.

Entain CEE confirmed the remaining composition of STS’ management board, managerial structure and plans for growth in the Polish market remain unchanged.

Central and Eastern Europe-facing Entain CEE was created in 2022 to make acquisitions across the region. Entain has a 75% stake in Entain CEE, with Emma Capital holding the other 25% stake.

Speaking last year, Mikolaj Cymerman, head of corporate development at Entain CEE, said the group was formed to exploit the region’s potential.

Rhode Island: Handle and revenue down in November

Bettors spent $48.3m (£38.2m/€44.1m) on sports wagering in Rhode Island in November. This was 21.1% down from $61.1m in 2022 but 5.5% ahead of $45.8m in October 2023.

Of this total, $38.6m was wagered with online sportsbooks in Rhode Island. A further $9.6m was spent at retail locations at Twin River and Tiverton Casino. Twin River took $6.0m worth of bets in November and Tiverton Casino $3.6m.

Revenue slips to four-month low in Rhode Island

As for revenue, this amounted to $3.4m. Not only was this 30.6% behind $4.9m generated in November 2022 but also 24.4% less than $4.5m in October 2023.

The Rhode Island Lottery also noted the November total was the lowest monthly amount since $1.4m was reported in August 2023.

Online betting accounted for $2.6m of all revenue in November. Retail’s share amounted to $837,173, of which $488,920 came from Twin River and $348,253 Tiverton Casino.

It was also noted that players won a total of $44.9m from sports betting during the month. Some $36.1m came from online wagering and $8.8m retail.

Financial year-to-date handle surpasses $170.0m

Looking at the financial year-to-date, total player spend in the five months through to the end of November was $174.5m. This included $136.8m from online betting and $37.7m retail.

Revenue-wise, this reached $13.7m for the five-month period. Online generated $11.7m in revenue and retail sportsbooks $3.0m.

Rhode Island players won $159.8m from sports betting in the reporting period.

Delaware: Igaming revenue rises in November – sports betting declines

Total igaming revenue in Delaware in November was $1.1m (£882,214/€1.0m). This was up 13.0% from $987,423 in November 2022 and 13.5% ahead of $982,919 in October 2023.

Of this total, $900,418 came from online video lottery games, $188,050 via internet table games and $27,170 from poker rake and fees.

In terms of spending, players in Delaware spent $32.1m on igaming in November. This was 24.8% lower than $42.7m in 2022 5.3% ahead of $30.5m in October. 

Video lottery games drew $23.4m in total wagers and table games $8.7m.

Delaware Park claimed top spot in the igaming market with $452,554 in revenue off $11.9m in wagers. Bally’s Dover placed second with $384,111 from $9.3m, then Harrington Raceway, posting $278,973 from £11.0m.

Declines in the Delaware sports betting market

Turning to sports betting, revenue in November amounted to $576,800. This was 62.3% less than $1.5m in November 2022 and also 78.0% behind October’s $2.6m haul.

Sports betting spend for the month was $8.1m. The Delaware Lottery said this was 20.6% behind $10.2m in 2022 and 24.3% less than $10.7m in October 2023.

Breaking down this market, Delaware Park also led the way with $368,904 in revenue off a $2.5m handle. Bally’s Dover followed with $54,588 off $1.0m, then Harrington Raceway on $19,476 from $364,706.

The Delaware Lottery also noted an additional $408,055 in revenue from $4.9m in wagers placed at retailers in November. 

Buzz Bingo rapped by ASA over Halloween marketing

A single complaint was filed to the ASA over the Buzz Bingo ad that appeared on Facebook in October 2023. Buzz Bingo published the advert on its Facebook page. 

The ad comprised animated footage of a full moon above a scene featuring pumpkin heads, a church with towers whose roofs resembled witches’ hats, bats flying, a spider in a web and a graveyard with a tombstone and a cross. In addition, text in a font resembling slime read “Monster Mondays – £50,000 must be won every Monday in October”.

The complaint alleged the cartoon Halloween imagery was likely to appeal to children and challenged whether it breached advertising rules.

Responding to the complaint, Buzz Bingo defended the advert. It said the ad appeared on its Facebook page that is restricted to Facebook users aged 18 years and above. It also said the ad was part of a campaign targeted at users aged over 25 with an interest in bingo.

Buzz Bingo said these steps meant it took precautions to prevent children and young people being exposed to the ad. However, it also acknowledged concerns the Halloween imagery could appeal to children and as such removed the advert and made changes to its internal marketing approval procedures.

ASA: Buzz Bingo advert must not appear again

Ruling on the case, the ASA upheld the complaint. It noted CAP Code guidance that adverts must not “be of strong appeal to children or young persons”. 

The Code also states animated content can contribute to the impression the material was designed to appeal to under-18s. As such, ads should avoid using child-like background imagery.

The ASA said Halloween and the traditions surrounding it were likely to have strong appeal for children. It also noted cartoon imagery in the ad was reminiscent of children’s cartoons and story books, while the term “monster” may appeal to children.

As such, it considered the ad was likely to be of strong appeal to children.

The ASA went further to say it would be acceptable for the advert to appear in a medium where under-18s could be excluded from the audience. However, this could only be for circumstances where those who saw the ad had been robustly age-verified as being 18.

As Facebook is a media environment where users self-verify on customer sign-up and do not use robust age-verification, the ASA considered Buzz Bingo had not excluded under-18s from the audience with the highest level of accuracy required for ads where content was likely to appeal strongly to under-18s.

The ASA also acknowledged the steps that Buzz Bingo took in response to the complaint. However, it concluded the ad was irresponsible and breached CAP Code rules 16.1 and 16.3.12.

Buzz Bingo was ordered to ensure the advert must not appear again in this form. The ASA also urged the operator not to include themes or imagery likely to have strong appeal to those under 18 years of age in future ads.

Guernsey risk assessment warns of laundering of foreign criminal proceeds

The Alderney Gambling Control Commission (AGCC), the supervisor of online gambling in Guernsey, played a key role in the NRA’s assessment.

Andrew Gellatly, recently appointed executive director of the AGCC, said he feels the regulator’s involvement with the NRA shows its commitment to matching high standards as a supervisor.

While highlighting foreign criminal proceeds, the NRA also pointed to the potential of money laundering related to domestic criminality. These risks were deemed to be much lower, however, with domestic offences largely related to drug trafficking and fraud.

Igaming links to money laundering in Guernsey

Guernsey’s role as an international finance centre inevitably means that it is at higher risk of attempts to launder the proceeds of overseas crime.

According to the NRA, Guernsey’s online casino sector’s money laundering risk was at medium. It deemed only four sectors to be at higher risk than igaming.

In 2022, online gaming accounted for 88% of all suspicious activity reports related to money laundering received by the Bailiwick of Guernsey’s Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU).

However, the total number of reports submitted in reference to online gambling was 28% lower than in 2021.

Stake seals exclusive F1 team title sponsorship

The exclusive deal will cover the 2024 and 2025 F1 seasons. Stake joined the Sauber team as a co-title sponsor last year, with the team known as Alfa Romeo F1 Team Stake for the duration of the 2023 campaign.

The team’s social media handles will be changed to reflect the new Stake F1 Team name.

According to Stake, the brand marked its entrance into F1 last year via a series of unique activations. These focused on cross-collaborations with the team’s other partners.

Stake planning activations

Stake is planning a series of high-profile F1 activations in 2024, including surrounding the launch of the new C44 car in February.

Team representative Alessandro Alunni Bravi said the new deal was “the natural and exciting next step”.

Bravi added: “Stake not only successfully tapped into Formula One’s growing fan base to enhance its own community… [It] also introduced a completely new audience to the sport.

“We had the opportunity to participate in some incredible activations with some of Stake’s ambassadors.”

Some of the activations featured the likes of Argentinian football legend Sergio Aguero and Indian-Canadian rapper Karan Aujla.

Value of F1 to Stake

Stake chief marketing officer Akhil Sarin highlighted the “marketing and media value… within the digital landscape”.

“The first phase of this partnership has succeeded in increasing global brand awareness for all stakeholders. At Stake, we are prepared to take the team’s reach, fanbase and visibility to unprecedented levels.”

Stake ventured into F1 a year ago after sealing other commercial partnerships in the sports industry. Previously, Stake secured exposure with English football club Everton, the Ultimate Fighting Championship and via English football’s FA Cup.

Links between F1 and betting tightening

Stake’s move into F1 marks the latest bond between racing and the betting industry, a relationship that was strengthened in 2024.

Las Vegas held its first ever Grand Prix back in November, attracting 300,000 fans to the city. As a result, Bet MGM took three times the number of bets of any other F1 race in its history.

The Grand Prix also boosted Nevada’s revenue for November, with a 12% year-on-year increase in gaming win thanks to punters flocking to the state.

The Nevada Gaming Control Board published figures showing the state’s establishments made some $1.37bn (£1.1bn/€1.3bn) in gaming revenue in November.

Win was up by 5.6% over the course of the most recent three-month period. Over the last 12 months, Nevada’s total gaming win is up 4.9% to $15.4bn.

Modernise casino rules before imposing extra costs, UK government warned

In an op-ed article for the Betting & Gaming Council (BGC), Rank Group’s David Williams said proposed changes that would benefit the sector must be introduced to ensure its survival.

Williams urges that these must come ahead of the lift in the National Living Wage and the expected impact of freezing casino duty bands. The latter will cost the sector £5m per year, according to the BGC.

Williams, Rank’s director of public affairs, said the industry can only survive these increased costs if policies outlined in the white paper are delivered first.

These include the change to gaming machine allocations and casinos being allowed to offer sports betting. Another key change, according to Williams, is the expansion of electronic payment methods.

Williams said the sector needs modernisation to drive revenue and help absorb costs. “That’s the only sequence of events that works,” he said.

Williams added: “These improvements cannot come a moment too soon and it is precisely why the industry is urging the government to keep its foot to the floor in delivering their response to the land-based consultation, laying the necessary statutory instruments and getting the legislation delivered in the first half of 2024. It all takes time, and whilst timing is everything, we are not blessed with time on our side.

“We are playing catch-up with casinos elsewhere in the world, and much of the wider gambling ecosystem. Only when the legislation is delivered can we set about making our casinos more modern and appealing.”

BGC accuses UK government of £5m casino stealth tax raid

In November 2023 the BGC accused the UK government of a stealth tax raid on casinos. It estimates that it could cost the industry £5m per year.

The claim relates to the freezing of gaming duty bands outlined in Chancellor of the Exchequer Jeremy Hunt’s autumn statement. In a statement, the BGC said that those within the land-based casino sector had hoped the bands would rise with inflation.

The BGC said the freeze in gaming duty bands effectively creates a £25m tax increase for casinos over the next five years.

Michael Dugher, chief executive of the BGC, has previously posited that the “stealth tax” has the potential to slow recovery and weaken future growth.

“Removing it would have provided a welcome boost for the land-based casino sector at a crucial time,” he said. “Instead, the decision to maintain the status quo represents a missed opportunity for companies ready and able to generate jobs and investment across the country.”

The BGC noted that casinos contribute £300m annually in taxes. Across the entire economy, the sector provides an estimated £800m a year in gross value.

However, casinos have been hit hard by challenges such as the cost-of-living crisis. The BGC noted that four casinos have closed in recent months, while the sector employs 25% fewer workers than just four years ago. One in four casinos have closed since 2005, with just 117 remaining across the country.

UK white paper consultations

Published in April, the Gambling Act review white paper outlines how gambling will be regulated in the UK. Several proposals set out in the white paper are currently being considered by the Gambling Commission. The first consultation was launched in July.

The BGC has broadly backed the government’s gambling white paper, notably in relation to casino reform. The white paper includes proposals on affordability checks, sports betting and machine numbers.

Round one, which closed in October, looked at financial risk and vulnerability and improving age verification at land-based venues. More than 3,000 submissions were made in total.

The next round of consultations considers seven topics including opting in for online bonuses. It is set to close in February or March, according to Tim Miller, executive director of policy at the Commission.

Study reveals reliability challenges for online gamblers in India

The findings were published in a new study by Ken Research into online gambling consumer behaviour in the country.

The study, entitled ‘Consumer Behavior Analysis for Online Gambling Industry in India’, outlined several reliability issues.

Primarily, for over 25% of online gambling participants, ‘challenges’ included various potential risks. These included “instances of fraud… unauthorised transactions, or complications associated with withdrawing funds.”

The report suggested that “India’s diverse cultural and legal landscape” contributed to the challenges.

“Different states in India had different regulations regarding gambling, ranging from outright prohibition to regulation,” it stated. “This patchwork of laws sometimes created uncertainty for both operators and users.”

Patchwork laws

Furthermore, only a tiny fraction of online gamblers have a “comprehensive awareness” of industry regulations. This could allow individuals to use unregulated operators.

The study cited “the intricate nature of the laws” and “limited exposure to in-depth information” for this challenge. In November, Indian authorities issued blocking orders against 22 illegal betting apps and websites.

This came just weeks after a new flat 28% turnover tax was imposed on licensed online gambling operators.

Last January, India’s government also published new rules to regulate online gambling.

Growth potential

However, the study also identified future growth potential.

In Delhi and Maharashtra, online gambling is particularly popular among 36 to 44-year-olds. In Uttar Pradesh, the activity is most popular among 26 to 35-year-olds.

The study added that a majority of 36 to 44-year-olds in Karnataka are active in online gambling. These users are active for between 11 and 20 hours per week.

Macau records 433% year-on-year December increase with MOP$18.6bn revenue

While gross gambling income in December was also 15.7% higher in Macau than the MOP$16bn recorded in November, it fell short of the MOP$19.5bn accumulated in October.

December was no doubt another strong month for Macau, however, taking the region to MOP$183.1bn in cumulative gross income for 2023. This is 333.8% higher than the MOP$42.2bn collected in the entirety of 2022.

Macau continuing to hit back from pandemic

Macau’s December income total was its second highest since before the COVID-19 pandemic. The constant year-on-year growth in Macau is largely down to the removal of all restrictions related to the disease.

Last year, casinos in Macau faced temporary closure, while travel to and from the region was restricted. However, the continued elimination of such hurdles has led to stunning financial growth, with visitors from outside China no longer having to quarantine.

One of the leading operators to benefit from such easing of restrictions in Macau was Melco Resorts & Entertainment. It reported a revenue hike of 320.6% to $1.02bn in Q3, with casino revenue jumping 346.2% to $812.1m.

Melco also posted $280.6m in positive adjusted EBITDA for the quarter. This was compared to a loss of $34.9m in the same period of 2022.

Macau success in spite of China struggles

Macau’s growth is made even more impressive when compared to the performances of China, which holds sovereignty over the region.

Lottery ticket sales in China for November decreased 2.5% year-on-year, while sports lottery sales were also down 13.3% from the same month last year.

However, welfare lottery sales reached CNY33.6bn (£3.7bn/€4.3bn/$4.7bn) across the country, a 29.5% year-on-year increase.

Southeast Asia, not Macau, expected to fuel regional gambling growth

Despite Macau’s recent success in attracting tourists and generating revenue, it still might not be the main driver of growth in the region.

In November, iGB looked at how Southeast Asia represents the greatest opportunity in the region’s gaming galaxy. It is also billed as the greatest competitive danger to established casino destinations, most notably Macau.

Industry expert Daniel Cheng even predicted the ASEAN bloc will overtake Japan within this decade. He added that too will become smaller in economic power than only the US, China and the European Union.